Our Top Picks Best Overall: Blue Cattle Truck Trading Co. Best No-alcohol: Danncy Clear Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract and Usumacinta Pure Mexican Vanilla . Best Vanilla Bean Paste: Blue Cattle Truck Trading Co. Best No-sugar: Totonac’s Pure Mexican Vanilla Flavoring. Best Dark: Danncy Dark Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract.
Pure vanilla is made with the extract of beans from the vanilla plant. Mexican vanilla is frequently made with the extract of beans from the tonka tree, an entirely different plant that belongs to the pea family. Tonka bean extract contains coumarin. Look for ” vanilla bean” on the label’s ingredient list.
Artificial vanilla extract is affordable , and is the vanilla extract predominantly sold in countries that produce vanilla beans. That’s why in Mexico , even though the country grows very fine beans, artificial vanillas dominate the market.
Vodka and Mexican vanilla beans are the two key ingredients I use to make this homemade Mexican Vanilla Extract.
Mexican vanilla that is produced by a reputable American company is pure vanilla extract made from Mexican beans. They may smell good because they don’t contain alcohol (or contain only 2% alcohol) but they are made from chemicals and are not pure vanilla . More information on Mexican vanilla here.
Vanilla prices have climbed so high it’s worth more by weight than silver. This increase in price has to do with a number of factors, including vanilla bean theft, complex pollination, extreme weather, and the rise of the “all natural” food movement.
The only significant difference is that in Mexico , the plant is pollinated by a bee and in Madagascar , humans need to pollinate the flower, leading to its higher price. (And despite the name, it is not actually made with bourbon whiskey; instead, “Bourbon” refers to a place where this vanilla was grown.)
It really doesn’t go bad unless improperly stored, but if you still have a bottle after 10 years it’s time to “freshen up” and buy a new, smaller bottle! As for your Mexican vanilla question, it’s one I get often – and I have a lengthy but interesting answer.
RE: Vanilla from Dominican Republic: Safe or Not ??? It’s a synthetic flavoring.
The 9 Best Vanilla Extracts of 2021 Best Overall: Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract at Amazon. Best Organic: Thrive Market Organic Vanilla Extract at Thrive Market. Best Budget: Great Value Pure Vanilla Extract at Walmart. Best Pure: Best for Ice Cream: Best with Seeds: Best Alcohol-Free: Best for Baking:
Coumarin does not come from cinnamon in Mexican vanilla – some folks will make ” vanilla ” out of tonka beans which have a vanilla – like taste .
Costco’s Kirkland Signature pure vanilla extract is an excellent find. The 16-ounce bottle, which will last you a very long time, is priced at $25 at our local Costco (compared to $12 for 4 fluid ounces at Trader Joe’s).
There is a slight difference in the taste. The dark vanilla is more intense. Also the dark vanilla will give a slight color change, where clear vanilla will not. If you want as white of a cake as you can get, use clear vanilla .
Why is vanilla extract so expensive ? Over 80% of the world’s vanilla is grown on the island of Madagascar, which has been recently hit with terrible weather. Failed crop yields have caused the prices of vanilla beans to soar to nearly $600 per kilogram, which is 10 times more expensive than it was a few years ago.